7/30 You make the call

Did you miss the controversial slide by the Cardinals’ Matt Holliday that upended Cubs shortstop Starlin Castro in the fifth inning Saturday? Here’s the video.


The Cubs didn’t question Holliday’s aggressiveness but did contend he made an illegal slide because he couldn’t touch the base. The Cubs led 5-2 when the Cardinals had two runners on and one out in the fifth. Albert Pujols, who had homered earlier in the game, was intentionally walked to load the bases and starter Rodrigo Lopez then walked Holliday to force in a run.

Lopez was pulled, and Jeff Samardzija took over and got David Freese to hit a grounder to second baseman Darwin Barney, who threw to Castro for the force. Holliday slid hard into the shortstop, and upended him. Holliday didn’t appear to touch the bag.

Both Cubs first baseman Carlos Pena and third baseman Aramis Ramirez went to Cousins to argue, and Quade then came onto the field to join in the discussion, which ended with the Cubs manager getting ejected for the fourth time this season.

“I applaud somebody for going in hard and trying to break up a double play to end an inning,” Quade said. “My thing is, it’s not a legal slide to me and that’s it.”

When Pena and Ramirez challenged Cousins’ call, Quade knew something wasn’t right.

“They don’t do that unless they feel that it was blatant and was out of the realm of what’s legal and what’s not legal,” Quade said of the two veteran infielders. “The rule is there for a reason.”

Castro was lucky Holliday wasn’t wearing metal spikes. His left shin was cut and raw from Holliday coming in high on the shortstop.

“It’s OK, because he didn’t have cleats,” Castro said. “If he had cleats, he would’ve cut me because he slid hard and way out of the base. It’s not good. It’s baseball. He tried to break a double play.”

Two runs scored on the play as Castro was down on the dirt, trying to regroup.

“I assumed he was hurt and waited to see what was going on with that,” Quade said. “At that point, somehow [throwing the ball home] was not on my mind. The fact that it could’ve been a double play and we could’ve been out of the inning was on my mind.”

But they weren’t, and the Cardinals scored eight runs in the fifth en route to a 13-5 win.

Quade had said he would do his best to not get ejected in the second half.

“I was pretty upset,” he said. “It was a combination of the play itself and the importance of it at that time had me really upset.”

Said Castro: “He’s out. He didn’t have a chance to touch the base.”

Said Cardinals manager Tony La Russa: “I watched it on tape. He’s sliding into the bag. He’s in the vicinity of the base.”

Guess it depends on your point of view.

“I disagree with Derryl’s assessment that it was a clean play,” Quade said. “I think that’s why they have the rule in place. I don’t think there was an attempt at the bag. He got a pretty good piece of Castro as well. That’s a huge play, obviously, in the game, too, and would’ve gotten us out with a 5-3 lead. I disagree a bunch, obviously, and fortunately Starlin is OK.”

— Carrie Muskat


Holliday should’ve been called out. Out of the baseline. I didn’t realize he wasn’t wearing spikes. That alone should spare him from getting plunked in the back Sunday night on ESPN. However, I would still like to see him take one in the thigh. Suppose you could argue that the hard slide is good hard baseball. Then too a plunk in the leg could be argued as good hard baseball as well.

Had this been Ramirez sliding into Theriot we would all be calling him a hero.

Play hard, win hard. At least the Cardinals have the desire to win.

Having sad that, had it been Ramirez it would have been the first thing he had run for since finding a money off voucher for Dunkin Donuts.

Rulebook Sec. 7.09
(d) Any batter or runner who has just been put out hinders or impedes any following play being made on a runner. Such runner shall be declared out for the interference of his teammate;

Holiday may have been able to reach the base, but he made no attempt to.
Cubs fan or not that is interference in my book

agree 100%. bad call ump. i think MLB owes the Cubs an apology.

Bad calls happen all the time. Horrendous calls happen less often. Good teams persevere through them and good managers do not act like a melodramatic 80 year old actress that is ready for her “close-up” as Quade is hell bent on doing all season as if it is the only way he can show he is “working hard” for the team. He’s over doing it and looks juvenile.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: