3/2 Could Soriano lead off? Why not?

Dale Sveum tried to downplay the significance of Friday’s intrasquad lineups but it was unusual to see Alfonso Soriano back in the No. 1 spot. Soriano has a career .288 average as a leadoff man with 197 of his total homers there. Soriano led off in one game last year, none in 2010, and 70 in 2009. Sveum said it’s not out of the question the left fielder could bat first in the regular season.

“The one thing about Soriano is that his numbers as a leadoff hitter are pretty good in his career,” Sveum said. “If you want to get into details of why you might come up with something like that, it could be as simple as that. We don’t have the bona fide guys at any position in the order. We don’t have any guys who have driven in runs in the big leagues. [Starlin] Castro is probably the most talented and best hitter we have to hit third. Do we have that base stealer to leadoff or an on-base guy? [David] DeJesus probably fills that as much as anyone. But we don’t have a lot of cut and dried spots where you say, this guy is this, this guy is that. It’s not that easy with this lineup.”

Sveum said he expects to finalize the lineup by the middle of March after he’s seen players in games. The ideal place for Soriano is in an RBI spot, Sveum said, and the same is true for Castro.

“He’s a great hitter,” Sveum said of the shortstop. “He’s proven to be able to do what he’s done in almost two years playing every day. That’s pretty impressive numbers to put up so that a guy like that should be put in an RBI spot. When and at what time, that’s always the million dollar question with young hitters. Can they handle hitting in the heart of the lineup?”

— Carrie Muskat


Please, God, no

Also a please no from me… except when it is to raise Soriano’s stats so he can/will be traded.

Soriano has a career .338 OBP as a lead-off hitter and has not done it regularly since putting up a sub-.300 OBP leading off for much of 2009. It drives me crazy when managers just say these things off the cuff without looking at any numbers.

Sveum is all ready grasping for straws. Rookie manager but still rooting for him.

Back to back central champs with him in the lead-off spot in 08-09. Then Lou decided it was Sori that was the problem not the fact that Lou wasn’t awake for most of those seasons. Put him in the lead off spot, what can it hurt?

Considering the options is it all that crazy? It is a sad however as all of us know that should the Cubs be stuck with Soriano there no longer is a good spot for him anywhere in the lineup or in the field. Sveum has got to be rooting for a trade to remove the one remaining albatross, allowing him to field players that can…well…FIELD. I agree with Ty, Sveum may be grasping at straws but what manager whether a rookie or not wouldn’t be hard-pressed to find a line up spot for Sorano? He’s not a disciplined hitter, he’s no longer fast and he’s no longer a guy the opposition fears in any RBI spot.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: